UK time is: 20:37:41
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Burnley 0 - Reading 1

Turf Moor

Saturday 15th October 2011 @3pm Kick-Off

Attendance: 13,664

Burnley Flop as Royals Shade It!

The Clarets, vastly improved of late put in a shocker of a performance against Reading at home on Saturday going down 1-0 thanks to a Royals goal deep into added time. Reading`s Jay Tabb had been knocked unconscious with 20 minutes to go after taking a fiercely cleared ball by Grant full on in the face. He was out cold for 30 seconds and was then stretchered off in a neck brace for hospital treatment. It looked serious but thankfully the news today is that he is fine and recovering well from his ordeal. The end-result on the pitch though, with the score at 0-0 after 90 minutes was nine minutes of added time. It looked set to end in a dreary, dull and dire goalless draw before substitute Jem Karacan (who had replaced Tabb in the 72nd minute) broke all Clarets fans hearts by shading a victory for the Royals with a goal in the final minute of added time. We perhaps could have expected a defeat against Reading. We may have won the all-important semi-final play-offs games a few seasons back on our way to promotion but Reading still remain a bit of a bogey team. The Royals thumped us 4-0 last season at home and got the double over us, indeed they have won eight out of the last eleven meetings so it was perhaps not too surprising that they took all the spoils again on Saturday. Our performance though in this game was dreadful and to be honest we did not deserve to win although a draw may have been a fairer result.

Both sides looked pretty poor but none more so than the disappointing Clarets who failed to get out of first gear at any time during the match, lacking energy and urgency for most of the game. Burnley seemed to resort to ineffective hoof ball instead of being creative in midfield and our strikers were nowhere to be seen for most of the game. Only Marvin Bartley showed any passion and determination to try and get something from this clash and he must have been frustrated by the performance of his lacklustre colleagues around him. Just what is it about International breaks this season? Just before the breaks we have now twice looked to be building momentum only to return after the break to suffer home defeats in shocking style. This is simply not good enough and there is no logical explanation for the drop in performance standards to such a degree. Going into this match against Reading we had been undefeated in three games after putting in some impressive performances against League leaders, Southampton (1-1 draw) and Forest (a tonking 5-1 win) at home before keeping our first clean sheet in 24 games in the match away to Millwall. That 1-0 victory against the Lions just before the international break was our first back-to-back win since April and we should have been buoyed up and ready to kick the Royals butts on Saturday. We should have gone into this game refreshed after the break and raring to go. Instead we looked tired, disinterested and lethargic

The fans expectations and hopes were high before kick-off but that all evaporated by the time of the final whistle. This miserable result and performance left a lot of Clarets fans frustrated and angry. The general consensus seems to be that if we continue to play with such contrasting inconsistency the best we can hope for now is probably a mid-table finish come the end of the season. At the moment, I think I would tend to agree, it is clear we might have a young squad with potential but that potential looks unlikely to be realised this season unless we can strengthen both in terms of quality and quantity. The team was crying out for old hands with experience yesterday and there was nobody to take up that mantle. The club seem happy to put up with the transition and they give the strong impression that would also not be too concerned if we didn`t get promotion this season. The Board certainly do not seem prepared to put any decent investment behind players to give Eddie Howe a greater chance of achieving Premier League status although all eyes will be on the January transfer window as well to see if that stance changes. We still have eyes on the loan market too but once again hope of a new signing this week went up in smoke despite Eddie Howe suggesting it was a possibility.

We should not throw in the towel just yet though. The Championship is notorious for teams being blessed with inconsistency and we all know form seems to go out the window so many times with virtually any team capable of beating any other on the day no matter what their position in the league table.

Burnley dropped one place to 15th spot after the Reading defeat but if Birmingham beat Leicester at home today (Sunday) we will drop another place. We now have 12 points from 10 games, just four points clear of the drop-zone but also just six points off a play-offs spot with a game in hand over most other clubs. Still all to play for of course and our fortunes could go either way but you just sense things will be stacked against us if we suffer any further injuries or suspensions and fail to supplement our squad further.

We now face three tricky away games on the trot and it is important we get something from these matches or confidence could really plummet. It`s Barnsley at Oakwell on Tuesday night followed by a trip to the Ricoh to face Coventry City this Saturday. These are another two clubs who are hardly setting the world alight in the Championship this season with both currently below the Clarets in the league table. We should be capable of getting some points from both these matches although of course there is no such thing as an easy game. If we don`t we could be on a low ebb going into the Carling Cup 4th Round clash away to Cardiff City a week on Tuesday and we need our spirits lifted before local rivals, Blackpool come-a-visiting in our next home league game on Saturday 29th October.

Team Sheet

David Edgar got the all clear ahead of this game despite concerns that he may have been shattered and still suffering jet lag after representing Canada during the international break in their CONCACAF World Cup 2014 qualifying games over the pond!

With Edgar keeping his place in the starting eleven, Ben Mee had to be content with a place on the bench yet again. Indeed Eddie Howe kept faith with the same sixteen for the fourth game running and there was perhaps no surprise in that considering our last three excellent performances in which we remained undefeated.

We lined up therefore as follows:

Grant, Trippier, Edgar, Amougou, Easton, Wallace, McCann, Bartley, Stanislas, Rodriguez, Austin

Subs: Stewart, Mee, Marney, Treacy, Hines

Full Match Report

Clarets fans were buoyant ahead of this game and on a nice bright warm day in Burnley hopes were high as Chris McCann led his side out onto the pitch. West Midlands referee, Phil Gibbs got the match underway and for the first few minutes Burnley looked to be taking the game by the scruff of the neck and putting the Royals under pressure. Rodriguez angled in a shot that took a deflection and flew across the face of goal with Austin unable to pounce. A throw in from Trippier allowed Wallace to unleash a shot but his left-footed effort flew over the top. Trippier and Wallace continued to link well down the right and set-up chances for both Rodriguez and Austin but in the end their effort came to nothing and gradually Reading started to get back into the match.

It was the Royals who came closest to taking the lead in the 27th minute. Gorkss put through a long ball that got the better of Amougou allowing Adam Le Fondre to get in behind the Clarets defence. The angle was tight but the former Rotherham striker got in a good shot that Grant did well to save at his near post. Le Fondre then thought he had scored after getting the ball in the net a few moments later. Grant had parried away a McAnuff cross into the path of Le Fondre but the assistant referee had raised his flag and the goal did not count much to the relief of Clarets fans.

Burnley were under pressure at this stage but managed to weather the storm during a 15 minute spell in which the Royals looked certain to take the lead. In first half stoppage time the Clarets had one last chance to break the deadlock before half-time. A Wallace shot took a deflection but the Royals keeper just managed to stop the ball looping under the crossbar.

A very disappointing first 45 minutes then with very few chances to talk about. Could things improve in the second half?

In truth no and our attack continued to look totally ineffective so much so that with just nine minutes of the second half played, Howe made his first substitution bringing on Treacy to try and inject some pace and steel into our wing play. Stanislas was the one to make way.

It made very little difference though although Bartley and Austin linked well to set up our best chance of the half. The impressive Bartley charged forward from midfield on a powerful run and then unleashed a shot after playing a neat one-two with Austin. Federici though was equal to the danger and managed to block the attempt at the foot of the post.

The game was rapidly becoming a dull, dire affair but all Clarets fans knew that a goal had to come soon for the Clarets with the possibility of losing out to Reading on the break always a threat.

The Royals too could sense this was anybody`s game and they came close to opening the scoring from a Mills corner. Simon Church attempted to head home but just failed in his attempt. The Royals then suffered the loss of Jay Tabb after he was knocked unconscious but it didn`t seem to put them off their stride. Noel Hunt came close from a Robson-Kanu cross but could only put his header just wide of target. The Royals then replaced Church with Manset in the 81st minute and his first touch of the ball involved curling an attempted shot on goal just wide.

Two minutes later and Reading were appealing for a penalty! It was former Reading defender, Andre Amougou (formerly known as Bikey) who was lucky to get away with it after seemingly bringing down Le Fondre. The linesman was surrounded by protesting Reading players but it came to nothing although Amougou was booked for suggesting too strongly that the player had dived!

After the treatment required to Jay Tabb it was no surprise when the fourth official flashed nine minutes of added time but the question was whether Burnley could now keep their second clean sheet in as many games. They clearly didn`t look like scoring one! It seemingly looked like both teams were going to have to settle for a goalless draw before Hunt got over a cross for Karacan to stab home a shot with just 30 seconds of added time remaining! Miserable end to a miserable afternoon then for all Clarets fans and such a disappointing result! Now we have to pick ourselves up again and try and get the form back we had before the cursed International break starting against Barnsley at Oakwell on Tuesday night

Match Stats

Burnley: Grant, Trippier, Edgar, Amougou, Easton, Wallace, McCann, Bartley, Stanislas (Treacy 55), Rodriguez, Austin

Subs Not Used: Stewart, Mee, Marney, Hines

Booked: Trippier, Amougou

Reading: Federici, Pearce, Mills, Gorkss, Cummings, Tabb (Karacan 72), Leigertwood, McAnuff (Hunt 46), Robson-Kanu, Le Fondre, Church (Manset 81)

Subs Not Used: McCarthy, Harte

Goal: Karacan 90+9

Booked: Mills

Possession: 54% Burnley, 46% Reading (Source BBC Sport)

Ref: Phil Gibbs (West Midlands)

Star Player

Only one player earned the title 'Star Player' after such a shocking team performance and that was Marvin Bartley. He was the only one who showed any determination, skill and energy in this match and fully deserved the fans texted man of the match award. He is looking the best of Eddie Howe`s buys to date and seems to be getting stronger and more influential in every game. Just a pity none of the other midfielders around him gave him the support he needed!




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: turfmanphil Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday October 16 2011

Time: 3:20PM

Your Comments

Nuff said about this one.Time to move on and forget this horror show!
turfmanphil
Down to 16th-Brum beat Leicester 2-0!!
turfmanphil
Clarke Carlisle was in the White Swan in Hebden Bridge last Wednesday night (on his own). I know that because I saw him. Could start all sorts of conspiracy theories on the strength of this. e.g. a sudden return? Nice little pub but not where you would expect to see him.
AndyHo
Expected roller coaster as we just hit the low, on the up Tue should be a draw. Maybe Clarke was on the way to Huddy.
cornwallclaret
Training for Monday, tie Austin Easton and Tubby tubby Treacy on the back of Eddies car and drive round Burnley with them running behind, that will get a few pound off em. The rest of the planks can run in front.
Grimsby Claret
poor poor performance!!! bartley shining star, pacey and determined however still let down by occasional poor first touches. think we need new captain, chris is a great midfielder but not a born leader, not vocal enough. need some more experience on the pitch. also would change edgar for mee to play alongside bikey. fingers crossed for tue night. come on you clarets!!!!
pie&peas
Owh I hope he wasnt on the beer (Clarky) he's done a fantastic job of getting that monkey off his back over the years, really turned his life around, he got done for being over the limit last week PLEASE CLARKE DONT GO DOWN THAT ROOT GET THE HELP YOU NEED NOW BUD
hollinsclaret
All very depressing and in truth you would struggle to see where the next decent performance is coming from. This reminds me of the Play-off run in last year i.e. we should beat so and so and we have all these games in hand. Ended on a whimper with n'owt to show for our efforts. Hopefully the lads can buck up and the Reading result will prove to be a blip. Fully agree with HC by the way, you have to be concerned when it is reliably reported that CC is in a boozer on his tod (probably cleaning out the Quiz machine tho').
Essex Claret
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Stoke 1 - 2 Burnley
Burnley 1 - 0 Hull City
Arsenal 3 - 0 Burnley
Burnley 1 - 3 Everton
Burnley 1 - 3 West Ham
Leicester City 2 - 2 Burnley

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
14. Sunderland 12 2 7 3 -7 13
15. Crystal Palace 12 3 3 6 -4 12
16. Aston Villa 12 3 3 6 -11 12
17. Hull City 12 2 5 5 -3 11
18. Leicester City 12 2 4 6 -7 10
19. Burnley 12 2 4 6 -12 10
20. Q.P.R. 12 2 2 8 -12 8

Breaking League News

Mixed Diame And Lenihan Injury News
Hull City : 25/11/2014 20:07:00
Robertson Attracting Interest
Hull City : 25/11/2014 20:05:00
Arsenal v Borussia Dortmund Match Preview
Arsenal : 25/11/2014 20:01:00
Stop Criticising Referees Neil!
Crystal Palace : 25/11/2014 19:43:00
Palace Join Senegalese Midfielder Chase?
Crystal Palace : 25/11/2014 19:41:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Our first win at last. How many more before Xmas?
Suggested By:  Vital Burnley Admin
6 2%
5 0%
4 16%
3 38%
2 19%
1 16%
0 9%