Burnley - Duff Game,Duff Ref,Duff Off
UK time is: 20:29:23
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Burnley 0 - Swansea City 2

Turf Moor

Saturday 10th January 2009 @5:20pm KO

Attendance: 13,740

Duff Game,Duff Ref,Duff Off

The Clarets suffered another humiliating defeat at home yesterday, this time going down to Swansea 2-0. The miserable Christmas period has continued into the early New Year and we have now gone five games in all competitions without a win.

One of those defeats included of course that truly disappointing and frustrating 4-1 defeat by Spurs at White Hart Lane in the Carling Cup Semi-final 1st leg last week. A result that truly flattered Tottenham but which also ensured we now need a miracle to reach the Wembley final in the second leg at Turf Moor later this month.

That game may well have taken the stuffing out of the Clarets both mentally and physically. It certainly looked that way against Swansea yesterday even before our task was made even more difficult by a crass refereeing decision. Michael Duff was ridiculously sent off for an alleged foul in the penalty area after 35 minutes play.

Owen Coyle was livid about the decision:

'The penalty was a big moment in the game and it was a hard one to take, we have been on the end of some harsh decisions"

This match was also of course a late kick-off thanks to the game being televised by Sky Sports and I have yet to see my Sky Plus recording. The general consensus though from folk I have spoken to was that this was never a penalty and certainly not a straight red.

How many red cards have Burnley had this season? We seem to get one every other game and most of them controversial and harsh. We are not a dirty team are we?

I think the FA have to look at this area in the future. Far too many games are being killed off by weak refereeing decisions and sending players off for something and nowt! I was thinking this at the game before I saw today that Owen Coyle has also since called for a rule change. He is 100% spot on!

Oh well, like I say although we were reduced to ten men for most of the game, we hardly shone in the first 35 minutes with eleven men and looked shadows of our former selves. We have to stop being beaten by such mediocre teams, we were just not good enough and had we played like we did for the first 45 minutes against Spurs, we would and should have annihilated them. Quite frankly I thought we were awful, the defence in particular although Chris Eagles looked totally disinterested and never seemed to get out of the starting blocks all afternoon.

This defeat ensured we now drop out of the play off positions for the first time since October. We are now 7th on 43 points. The day was made even worse with the earlier news of Preston beating Wolves at Molineux and the Lilywhites are now one point ahead of the Clarets in 6th place which really sets us up nicely, but worryingly for the local derby at Deepdale next Saturday.

What has happened to our team? Are the injuries, suspensions and tiredness beginning to catch up with the lads? We still have a relatively small squad, even more so with Anderson out with cruciate ligament injuries, Kiraly not wanted and Jones and Berisha again out on loans.

Maybe this is just the half-a-season phenomenon again; you know the Clarets traditional post-Christmas slump.

Something though is quite clear, if Kilby and Flood are adamant they want to see this club in the top-flight, we are going to have to go the final mile in the transfer windows sometime, hold onto to our key players and preferably add to the squad. The news is grim at the moment on that front with only loans looking likely if that. Our fate this season could be decided by the shape of our squad come 1st February but somehow we have to get back to winning ways and quickly before then.

Caldwell returned to the side yesterday after a two-match automatic ban for his straight red-card sending off at Doncaster.

Clarke Carlisle who has had some indifferent games in the back four for the Clarets recently was dropped for this match and Michael Duff took his place in the centre of defence, partnering the skipper.

It was perhaps also surprising that Gudjonsson started this game having been passed fit afterall. Owen Coyle had stated the Icelandic midfielder was going to be rested after coming off with a potential hamstring problem in the Spurs game. It was Kevin McDonald in fact who didn`t make the sixteen confirming he still hasn`t fully recovered from his groin injury despite coming on for Gud at White Hart Lane.

We therefore lined up as follows:

Jensen, Alexander, Duff, Caldwell, Jordan, Eagles, Elliott, Gudjonsson, McCann, Blake, Paterson.

Subs: Penny, Carlisle, Mahon, MacDonald, Thompson

The only potential interest in the Swansea team for Clarets fans was whether we would get chance to see our former loan star, Nathan Dyer currently on loan from Southampton play for the Swans. Well there would be a chance as he was named on the bench.

Do you ever get those pre-match feelings that things are not going to go our way? I just had a feeling against Swansea we would be lacklustre with the stuffing taken out of us after the gruelling midweek Spurs game. You just knew also with Preston winning, we would struggle to get a win and so it proved.

On a cold, bitter afternoon at Turf Moor, Northumberland referee Michael Oliver got the game underway.

It was the visitors who had by far the better start with the Clarets looking jaded and clueless. Swans, Mark Gower had a shot deflected wide for a corner after 11 minutes.
The back-four then needed a good waking up after Darren Pratley got behind them on 14 minutes only to find Jensen bravely stopping his advance.

'For heaven`s sake, Burnley start playing like you did in the first half against Spurs, this is bloody Swansea` I found I kept saying that to myself countless times as Swansea time and time again went up on the attack. Jensen was alert again on 21 minutes this time mopping up a low cross by Pratley.

It was nearly 30 minutes for heaven`s sake before our first real chance when Paterson got in a great cross only for McCann`s header to be deflected wide. That seemed to stir us into action and one minute later Eagles woke up but could only fire over. He then got in a superb cross on 31 minutes with Paterson just failing to connect.

This was the only time in the match that I thought we might stand a chance of getting a result with the Clarets beginning at long last to take control .That thought though evaporated four minutes later when the referee spoilt the game with a pathetic penalty decision and sending off.

Michael Duff looked to have his hands around Jason Scotland`s midriff but the striker`s progress didn`t seem to be impeded and by the time the challenge came in, his hands were no longer round the big Trinidadian. If it was a foul it was an innocuous one, and if it was a penalty it certainly didn`t warrant a red-card. Misery complete for the Clarets fans though, off goes Duff and in goes Scotland`s spot kick.

Roberto Martinez's side saw out the rest of the first half with some ease now they had the extra man advantage and as the referee blew for the end of the first half, I hope he took on board the booing and disgust of the Clarets fans as he walked off (probably not!)

Swansea started the second half as they had ended the first half, enjoying most of the possession and using their one-man advantage. Thankfully Gower inside the area could only shoot straight at Jensen on 50 minutes.

Thompson came on for Blake after 56 minutes with Coyle trying to freshen things up and then Swansea brought on our former loan winger, Nathan Dyer eight minutes later.

Burnley had one or two moments in the second half without really looking that convincing. Elliott got in a near-lethal cross on the hour mark but again Paterson just failed to make contact.

By now the neutrals watching this game on Sky Sports were probably asleep as the game deteriorated into a scrappy, lifeless affair.

With the ball bouncing around in the box, McCann was unlucky not to get a connection on the ball with 74 minutes played but 10 minutes later and the Clarets miserable afternoon was complete with Scotland getting his brace for the Swans. Gower had made a good run down the left crossing the ball for Scotland who easily slotted home from close range.

The Clarets though did still try and get something from the game but it just seemed hopeless and it was typical that attempts by Eagles and Paterson late in the game both sailed over the angle.

It was almost a relief when the final whistle went and those Clarets fans still on the ground could go home and warm up. We have to do something and something quick to reverse the misery of these torrid times. So that`s three straight defeats in the Championship now and a mountain to climb in the Carling Cup. Does anybody really relish an FA Cup 3rd round replay at home to QPR on Tuesday night? Well that`s what we have got and it is probably one match we can ill-afford to have in a packed January schedule. I just hope that tit of a referee hasn`t ensured it effectively means our Championship promotion hopes have gone tits-up and another post-Christmas slump and midtable mediocrity is all we can now look forward too. Aye, I know be positive!


Burnley: Jensen, Alexander, Duff, Caldwell, Jordan, Eagles, Elliott, Gudjonsson (MacDonald 86), McCann, Blake (Thompson 56), Paterson.

Subs Not Used: Penny, Carlisle, Mahon.

Sent Off: Duff (35).

Booked: Elliott.

Swansea: De Vries, Rangel, Williams, Tate, Monk, Britton, Gomez (Pintado 87), Pratley, Gower, Scotland, Allen (Dyer 64).

Subs Not Used: Konstantopoulos, Butler, Serran.

Booked: Britton.

Goals: Scotland 35 pen, 86.

Ref: Michael Oliver (Northumberland).

Star Player

I don`t think any of our players deserve the title 'star' to be honest based on that performance. There was only one star and that was for Swansea. His name? Michael Oliver. Without him, we might have got a point with eleven men but then we were awful anyway!

Our best player was probably Brian Jensen and we have to thank him for keeping the score down.

The Journalist

Writer: turfmanphil Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday January 11 2009

Time: 4:12PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Let's just be honest here! We are never going to get anywhere unless we freshen up this squad for the second half of the season, especially in defence. They look jaded, shell-shocked and clueless at the moment. We simply cant afford to keep dropping points against the likes of Barnsley, Doncaster & Swansea
Report Abuse
11/01/2009 16:17:00

mediocre? if we were mediocre I'd like to know what you were. Phil, I think you've underestimated us here as we were fully worthy of our win. You seem to think you have the right to beat us at home because we're 'only swansea' if you haven't noticed we're 10th, not too far behind yourselves and we outperformed you on your own patch.
Report Abuse
11/01/2009 16:42:00

You beat 10 men who were lifeless,clueless and looked knackered. I think they were physically and mentally drained after Spurs but we have been going downhill since Boxing Day. I am sorry but had you played the team that turned up for the first 45 minutes at White Hart Lane or the team that saw us climb to 4th for most of October-December, I doubt you would have found it so easy and would have been struggling. You passed the ball well but I suspect you will finish where we have for most of the last few seasons, midtable and if we are not too careful we could be joining you [Edited by turfmanphil]
Report Abuse
11/01/2009 16:49:00

it doesn't matter, about ifs, its football. we play whats in front of us, we beat 10 men yes but we dominated even when you had 11. you're looking for excuses now and if, IF you were all knackered then changes should have been made to put out a more fitter team.
Report Abuse
11/01/2009 17:02:00

We have one of the smallest squads in the league, one less than you in fact and out of those,one is a third-string keeper we want shut of, two are out on loan yet again(Jones/Berisha) and one is out for a season with a cruciate! Yesterday, McDonald was out again with a groin injury and Van der Schaaf still out with a kidney problem. and one was our substitute keeper,Penny. We played two subs yesterday. Who exactly are we supposed to play that are fit?
Report Abuse
11/01/2009 17:57:00

Just a reply to the clown who wrote this article, who are you calling mediocre! the swans totally played you off the park even before the penalty and sending off. i sugest you go home and look at your sky+ recording to look at the penalty incident, if it was a rugby match it would have been a bloody good tackle!! duff had both hands on scotlands waist before he went down, a foul in any referees eyes, and denying a scoring opertunity the guy has got to go. and by the way, we,ve played every one of the teams above you off the park this season apart from reading who we will sort out next saturday!!!!!!.
Report Abuse
11/01/2009 18:02:00

Thank you for the clown remark although I must admit that does apply to the Clarets who never turned up at this Circus. Yes you played us off the park because we were crap and you only had to beat 10 men! That doesn't mean you were not a mediocre team. No point in playing all the top teams off the park if you are still only 10th, looks like the other teams below them have played you off the park? But thats the Championship! You will finish midtable this season I suspect but if not I will eat humble pie
Report Abuse
11/01/2009 18:30:00

Is that the Jacks fans getting defensive !!...fact is we (Burnley) were crap on the night, You deserved to win, likewise we deserved the 3 points at the Liberty. Both clubs need to be realistic ...we aint strong enough to support a sustained period in the top six, with luck both teams could get up in there...Would certainly prefer the Jacks up there than Cardiff.....UP THE CLARETS !!!
Report Abuse
12/01/2009 13:28:00

Not the best of games was it? One positive was Eagles backtracking At least you don't have a brother-in-law who is a Preston fan texting we are above you before the game had even started dam it
Report Abuse
12/01/2009 14:23:00

your comments are full of bitterness phil. You have championship experience, you've been in the league long enough where as we have none, we havent been at this level for 25 years. martinez has built a squad for around the same amount of money you spent on chris eagles. we also have 2 left backs out, playing a right back, plus our most important player Bodde out injured. we beat 10 men yes, but as we keep saying, you weren't even in the game when you had 11, and fully deserved the 3 points. and even more excuses from you for why you lost.
Report Abuse
12/01/2009 15:38:00

Wow the Jacks fans coming on here being all defensive about their team are starting to sound exactly like the bluebird fans I work with....ARE U CARDIFF IN DISGUISE.... UTC
Report Abuse
12/01/2009 18:56:00

I was perhaps a little insensitive about some of my comments, but Swansea fans shouldn't take it so personally. the point I was trying to make was that the Clarets have played their socks off in some games and have to me looked like a Premier League side on occasions against the likes of Chelsea, Arsenal and Spurs (45 mins). They too have also done well to be in Top 6 for most of 2008. But we now appear to be in a slump and with all due respect to Swansea they have to earn their Spurs yet in this League and indeed are certainly no Spurs either! The 'This is bloody Swansea nor Spurs' comment could equally apply to to any club in midtable and below. I wish Swansea well and they beat us fairly and squarely, but we were utterly awful,not to mention playing with only 10 men for most of game after a debatable sending off. The question we all have to ask is whether this result would have been the same had we played them before Christmas. I don't think it would have been. Like i say though if Swansea are more than midtable by end year they will have arrived and I will have to eat humble pie
Report Abuse
13/01/2009 08:17:00

In fairness, I thought Swansea looked a decent side. Yes they were on top 11 v 11 - but how many had they scored? and which team was coming back into it? Pato or Mccann could quite easily have put the clarets in front! As for the peno - every report i have read states that it was debatable - which makes the comments above about it being a rugby tackle seem bizarre. Yes Duff had his hands on Scotland - but did he drag him back? or did Scotland decide to go down after contact? Could Caldwell have still got to Scotland in any case? Although Swansea started the game well - It was still 0-0 until that decision and we will never know the final score had the pen not been given. It is not bitterness ( and I am sure it is not from Phil either) I think both of us are decent sides who play good football - ultimately we wll both probably finish outside the playoffs in 7th-12th!
Report Abuse
13/01/2009 21:47:00

can i just say what a total tw*t the guy who wrote this article is!!! he sounds a right arrogant pillock!! im sick of most of the sides in this league now with all their pathetic excuses as to why they lost to us always the same " we had injuries, we were awful" i find it strange how every time we beat a team theyve had a stinker strange that but there you go and now burnley are joining in !!! to be fair when you visited us i had nothing but praise for your side thought you played very well organised disciplined good width with clinical finishers! and probably deserved to win!!! but you didnt see any of our lot making pathetic excuses saying we were dreadful!!! cant people see now that nearly every manager so far in this league has said we are one of if not the best passing sides in the league!!! yet every time we dominate a game and quite fairly outplay their team on their own patch you get some fans who cant take it and disrespect our club. weve beaten the top side wolves 3-1 beaten preston 2-0 away beaten burnley 2-0 away drew 0-0 with birmingham at st andrews when we should have won very comfortably ! so how on earth can we be a mediocre team! also if were gona be slating teams heres my views on your team! i thought your team is extremely average and very predictable!! since we first played you the only threat you had was eagles and that was only because he switched to the right wing because up until then our right back rangel had him tucked away in his pocket while he was on the left!! also our midfield completely outplayed yours ive heard good things about mccann and gudjonsson but prately britton and joe allen looked head and shoulders above them!!! better on the ball and quicker to it!!! also i agree about the debate of the red card that maybe was harsh but im sorry in my opinion that is a STONWALT PENALTY! he had both arms around scotland which by the way is against the rules and was clearly holding him back!!! to me it was a good touch from scotland that got him away from duff and duff was on the complete wrong side of him and tugged him back end of!! sorry this may seem like a rafel benitez type rant but it just frustrates me so much when we play well against a side and receive no praise just disrespecting comments which half the time are ludicrous!! cmon burnely fans im asking give credit where its due and stop making excuses!!! your a decent side woll be pushing for playoffs so if you lose a game as you will do like the rest of us give credit wheres its due !!! best of luck for the season !!! p.s. sort the guy who wrote this article out total TW*T!!!
gors jack
Report Abuse
14/01/2009 09:45:00

Get over it and move on! No need to be insulting either
Report Abuse
14/01/2009 10:10:00

good line there coming from the guy who calls our club mediocre when wed just beaten them 2-0 on their own patch !!!
gors jack
Report Abuse
14/01/2009 10:28:00

Like I say get over it you won FFS,! It's all said above and you wont change my opinion of Swansea. One of many midtable teams and Burnley might be joining you if we continue to have these awful games
Report Abuse
14/01/2009 10:40:00

what an arrogant**** you really are !!! i dont give a ***** that you think were midtable because you see we are midtable and dont mind it first season here all we want is a bit of respect but clearly we dont get that from *****ers like you!!!!
gors jack
Report Abuse
14/01/2009 10:51:00

You are seriously over-reacting mate but that's your problem anyway I wish you well for the rest of the season and now can we draw a line under this?
Report Abuse
14/01/2009 12:01:00

you are overreacting Jack. It has been said that Swansea are a good footballing side - probably one of the best in the division. But it is also a fact that the clarets were below par on Saturday. Surely you have some frustration when Swansea dont play to standard!
Report Abuse
14/01/2009 12:22:00

He Gors Jack.....u a bluebird in disguise...u sounds like the gorillaz i drink with in Cathays....chill
Report Abuse
15/01/2009 20:48:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Burnley 1 - 0 Hull City
Sheff Wed 1 - 1 Burnley
Burnley 4 - 1 Derby County
Brentford 1 - 3 Burnley
MK Dons 0 - 5 Burnley
Burnley 0 - 0 Ipswich

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Hull City 29 17 5 7 +26 56
2. Burnley 29 15 10 4 +23 55
3. Middlesbrough 27 16 5 6 +22 53
4. Brighton 28 14 10 4 +9 52
5. Sheff Wed 29 13 11 5 +13 50
6. Derby County 29 12 12 5 +10 48
7. Birmingham 29 13 7 9 +8 46

Burnley Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Forest : 06/02/2016 20:18:00
Charlton : 06/02/2016 20:13:01
Cardiff : 06/02/2016 20:07:01
Hull City : 06/02/2016 20:00:01
Injury Time Goal Beats Millers
Rotherham : 06/02/2016 19:56:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Hull MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Heaton 0%
Lowton 0%
Keane 0%
Mee 0%
Ward 0%
Boyd 0%
Barton 0%
Jones 0%
Arfield 0%
Vokes 0%
Gray 0%
Sub - Hennings 0%