Burnley - One Match Ban for Caldwell
UK time is: 22:40:30
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

One Match Ban for Caldwell

Steven Caldwell was sent-off after being given a straight red in stoppage time against West Ham at Upton Park last Saturday. As we entered 5 minutes of added time and with the score at 5-2 to West Ham Caldwell cynically pulled back Hines earning himself the red card. Hines may well have made it 6-2 were it not for the foul but would that have made much difference? Some fans who had already given up on this game would have preferred Caldwell to be available for the Pompey match although at the end of the day goal difference could be an important factor that decides whether we stay up or not at the end of the season. In the end the game finished 5-3 after a late Eagles goal; a goal that prevented Blackburn going above us so it wasn't all bad news!

The captain now receives an automatic one-match ban and will therfore be suspended for our next game against Portsmouth at Fratton Park this Saturday.

The loss of our captain will be a blow but at least Owen Coyle has a number of options in the back-four for the Pompey clash.

These options would appear to be

1.Jordan in centre, Kalvenes at left back

2.Bikey back to central defence, Joey Gudjonsson or Kevin McDonald in midfield.

3.Duff in centre

4.Edgar in centre.

What do you reckon? Comment on your preferred option below this article or in our forums.

Bookmark and Share

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: turfmanphil Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday November 30 2009

Time: 12:05PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
I suspect the easiest option will be to recall Duff to partner Carlisle in the centre although I would like to see Edgar given a chance. The latter probably wont happen though since we don't seem to have sorted out Edgar's transfer fee yet with Newcastle and if this goes to a tribunal,appearances could increase his perceived value
Report Abuse
30/11/2009 12:09:00

No 4 Bikey in defence McDonald in his place in the midfield Kalvenes in place of Jordon but this is not gonna happen is it lol.
Report Abuse
30/11/2009 12:11:00

Ok i can't count lol i was suprised to see it was only a 1 match ban for him phew.
Report Abuse
30/11/2009 12:14:00

The incident looked even worse on MotD than at the time in the stadium (not that tmp and I could see much from our 35 seats!). It was a routine keeper's hack upfield, not a crafted through ball. Taken together with Caldwell having been very, very fortunate not to have conceded a penalty earlier, would Coyle have actually wanted to select Caldwell against Pompey after this horrible gaffe? Oh well, we like Coyle's deep sense of loyalty when turning down Celtic, so we have to live with that same loyalty being shown to his players. So, given that Duff goes on the bench ahead of Edgar, it should be Duff to replace Caldwell, with Bikey continuing to practice being a midfielder. But, with Nugent unavailable, lets start Big Kev with Robbie coming off the bench to score a last 10-minute hat-trick.
Couch Potato
Report Abuse
30/11/2009 17:13:00

I would go for Bikey back to centre half and start big Kev. I think I would also start Fernando ahead of Robbie.
Report Abuse
30/11/2009 18:07:00

Not sure how many times Caldwell has been sent off in a Burnley shirt but am sure I have seen him get a red card on AT LEAST three occasions in the last twelve months.
Report Abuse
30/11/2009 18:45:00

That's my second time. Donny away was the other time for me.
Couch Potato
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 07:35:00

I wonder if Caldwell will struggle to get back in if the back four look solid against Pompey? I often wonder if Caldwell would be the automatic selection he appears to be if he wasn't also the Captain
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 07:48:00

Championship defending needs to become Prem Defending. Play Duff alongside Carlisle as they have perhaps a better understanding at this moment than any other pairing. However I think he will put Bikey alongside Carlisle, I wouldn't!
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 08:03:00

This defending thing is getting to be a dilemma for me! It seems we are better at it at home by far than we are away. Why is that? If we could defend like we do in the main at home on the road, we might at least be getting better results away. Having said that, we do still have to get much better in this department. Can we do that with players who in the main are Championship quality or do we have to bring in defenders with more Prem experience? Can you teach an old dog new tricks?
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 08:51:00

Must agree with you Vin Duff to play alongside Carlisle, but we also need to sort Jordan out I know its not just down to him but it does seem to be his fault a lot of goals are scored, or am I having a pick on Jordan week.
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 09:32:00

Do you know sheclaret I think Jordan is prone to be Mr Unlucky, if a deflected own goal is going to happen its him, if a penalty is going to be conceded its down his side, if a player is going to play them onside for a goal its him. Yet he did a magnificent tackle against Villa to save us. I just have him down as Mr Unlucky! As for tmp, one question not raised yet....dare I.......Is Steve Davis earning his money? How much is he involved with the weekly training of the defence or is it Sandy's department?? OC takes ultimate responsibility but........
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 09:59:00

I don't honestly think Jordan has been that bad this season, he has got in some crucial tackles in my opinion. Not sure Blake is coming back to protect Jordan enough and maybe Robbie's pace is letting him down these days in that respect. Eagles and or Elliott with Mears on the opposite flank seem to work better in supporting each other [Edited by turfmanphil]
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 10:01:00

After the last 20 at WHU, when he was sensational, Eagles should be given a very extended run on the left flank. He also has more gas in his tank for getting back. Jordan should not have been on the pitch. The official Bfc site revealed he had struggled midweek with a virus, which has to be why Kalvenes was back on the bench. Coyle was caught out by trying too hard to keep an unchanged team. Jordan was unlukcy and at 95% rather than 100% mental speed. For the record, I would blame Carlise for Franco's header. He stood waiting, rather than attacked the cross. (Franco looks a bit good.)
Couch Potato
Report Abuse
01/12/2009 10:17:00

Big player, missing for a big game!!!
Report Abuse
02/12/2009 09:51:00

Plenty of cover just a question of who!
Report Abuse
02/12/2009 22:10:00

Hmmm, I'd have Bikey at Centre back and give Super Kev Mcdonald a chance in the centre. Alexander is there to be the holding midfielder, Elliott and McDOnald will just have to defend more. McDonald is a big lad too, he brings a good bit of height for winning headers in midfield. Can we leave Jordan alone, gosh he gets some stick! Kalvenes would get mullered in Premier League. MULLERED! He is about as quick as a one legged beetle! Lets look back to Play off final, Kalvenes's lunge that could have been a penalty? He simply is not quick enough! I'd give Guerrero a game too, give Robbie a rest.
Report Abuse
04/12/2009 15:28:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Burnley Articles

Vital Preview - Cardiff City v Burnley (Friday November 27 2015)

Vokes Could Face Cardiff (Friday November 27 2015)

Darikwa Gaining Interest? (Friday November 27 2015)

Audio - Arfield's Ten To Tackle (Thursday November 26 2015)

Audio - Dyche Talks Vokes (Thursday November 26 2015)

Match Day Officials v Cardiff (Thursday November 26 2015)

Gray The Record Breaker? (Wednesday November 25 2015)

Whitmore Makes Chester Move (Wednesday November 25 2015)

Vital Report - Burnley 1-1 Brighton (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Dyche & Mee Pleased With A Point (Monday November 23 2015)

Archived Burnley Articles

List All Vital Burnley Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Burnley 1 - 1 Brighton
Wolves 0 - 0 Burnley
Burnley 3 - 1 Fulham
Burnley 2 - 1 Huddersfield
Blackburn 0 - 1 Burnley
Forest 1 - 1 Burnley

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
2. Brighton 17 9 8 0 9 35
3. Middlesbrough 17 10 3 4 13 33
4. Derby County 17 9 6 2 13 33
5. Burnley 17 9 6 2 9 33
6. Birmingham 17 8 4 5 6 28
7. Reading 17 7 6 4 7 27
8. Sheff Wed 17 7 6 4 3 27

Burnley Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

RUFC - Lenighan Will Give 'One Hundred Per Cent'
Rotherham : 27/11/2015 22:24:00
RUFC - Warren Out On Loan
Rotherham : 27/11/2015 21:58:01
Hull City : 27/11/2015 21:32:01
Boro hope to bridge gap
Middlesbrough : 27/11/2015 21:10:01
Vital Match Preview - Wednesday at Blackburn Rovers
Sheff Wed : 27/11/2015 19:28:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Cardiff City v Burnley
Suggested By:  VitalBurnley
Burnley win 50%
Cardiff win 0%
Draw 50%