Vital Football

Latest Burnley FC News

Friday's Rumour Mill-McCarthyism & Tudgayism

Friday's Rumour Mill-McCarthyism & Tudgayism

Owen Coyle and the lads are now firmly ensconced on the West Coast after flying out to America yesterday for the start of their US Tour.

Whether that means we can expect a lull in transfer activity during their stay in the US remains to be seen although this is now a shrinking world when you consider all the modern communications available to the club.

There are certainly no new rumours to report this morning but there are some updates on two of our reported targets, Marcus Tudgay and James McCarthy.

We look to have lost out on James McCarthy who looked virtually certain to be joining Mick McCarthy's mob at Wolves until Wigan entered the race. Hamilton are reported to have accepted Wigan's £2.6million bid.

Accies are understood to have previously accepted a £2.5m plus £500,000 add-ons offer from Wolves for the 18 year midfielder but James McCarthy appears to have turned down the Molineux club. According to the Sun newspaper today he looks likely to now join Wigan and will be having a medical today after the two clubs agreed a deal

The Republic of Ireland Under-21 international of course was linked with a move to Turf Moor but Owen Coyle's valuation of the player did not meet Hamilton's expectations and the Wolves and Wigan offers are virtually double the bid we put in.

So it now looks certain that he wont be joining his Hamilton team mate, Brian Easton who signed for the Clarets this week although at one time McCarthy looked keen to come to Turf Moor in view of the considerable Scottish connection and set-up

The war of words over Burnley's interest in Marcus Tudgay continues with his agent, Darryl Powell once more calling the shots with Sheffield Wednesday again on the receiving end after they made stern accusations on the Official Owls website about the behaviour of Burnley FC and Powell.

Marcus Tudgay clearly wants to have talks with Burnley FC and achieve his dream of playing in the top flight.In my opinion it has been just a simple overreaction from the Owls board. All Burnley FC have done is bid for a player we liked the look of before someone over the Pennines started using inflammatory language which quite frankly has now turned the whole saga into a war of words! The exchange is mainly between agent and Wednesday I hasten to add although Burnley have been accused of underhand tactics. Unsettling a player my arse, he's a big boy now, he can decide what his own ambitions are and surely everybody can see that a chance to play in the top flight would be every player's dream. All Wednesday had to say was that the offer did not come up to their valuation of the player and leave it at that instead of which they start chucking their toys out of the pram in full gaze of the media with poor Tudgay caught up in the middle of it all. No wonder according to his agent, he is now considering handing in a transfer request.

Powell speaking to said:

'Marcus wants to go to Burnley and he is disappointed that they have rejected a bid for him. Like any player, Marcus wants to play in the Premier League and we are considering all our options. I plan to sit down with Marcus next week and we will decide what is best for him to do.Obviously handing in a transfer request is an option and we will talk through all our options.Marcus is not thinking of signing the new deal on offer [from Wednesday] and he is ready to wait and see what happens. Marcus is a bit miffed that an offer of £2million in the current financial climate is thought as being derisory. To call the bid derisory was a bit rude I thought for a player who is entering the final year of his contract.'

So this saga looks set to run and run but whatever happens the ball is now firmly in Wednesday's court and they will have to think very carefully how they intend to hold onto a player who will clearly be totally demotivated if they thwart his Premier League ambitions.

For the very latest Premier League odds

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Friday July 17 2009
Time: 9:29AM


I have a feeling Tudgay will be a Burnley player by the start of the season!
17/07/2009 09:35:00
I spotted the headline on teletext two clubs in for McCarthy and thought its us then discovered it was Wigan,who knows on the Tudgay front i just hope it doesn't go on and on and on
17/07/2009 11:52:00
Dont think owt will happen till after US tour if anything does but we shall see
17/07/2009 12:49:00
Guys, I have a lot of respect for you all and wish this whole saga with Tudgay had never happened, but it says a lot really, as far as the actual offer is concerned, that Owen Coyle only offered half the amount McCarthy was sold for. It just cements our position that Tudgay is also worth more than he offered. Add that to the fact that he ended up paying a million more than he originally offered for the guy from Hibs and maybe you can see where we're coming from. Not saying that I agree with all the crap that's happened either and, if it helps, most of us blame the weasel Powell, his agent, not you guys.
US Owl
17/07/2009 15:04:00
Really!! US Owl is this the same respect you give us on Vital SW to quote get real you west ham lookalikes and call us a tin-pot club if that's respect you can keep it thanks
17/07/2009 15:52:00
Think we may all need to chill about this Tudgay thing, it's bringing out the worst in all of us. I suspect if the Owls board hadn't made such a big issue of this and mentioned words like 'derisory' and 'unsettling Tudgay' all this would have blown over by now. [Edited by turfmanphil]
17/07/2009 15:58:00
I think the SWFC chairman is an amateur. Clubs making bids is how football works. We bid, SWFC turn it down the end. It did not need the statement he made. The only person who has unsettled Tudgay is the Owls chairman. He should have had a quiet chat with Tudgay and try and resolve it ,not slag off Burnley. By slagging us off all he did was make this situation alot worse.
17/07/2009 18:01:00
you made interest public before making an official bid though thats not how football works
17/07/2009 19:53:00
Not sure that's correct,Burnley made a verbal enquiry about Tudgay initially. I suspect it was his agent who leaked it to the press but then that's what they all do! [Edited by turfmanphil]
17/07/2009 20:13:00
Update on McCarthy for a bit of a change: Wolves are optimistic they can beat Celtic and Wigan to the signature of Hamilton midfielder James McCarthy (Daily Star) but Spurs have made a late move to hijack the deal according to Daily Mail
18/07/2009 09:46:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Burnley Articles

Eight Out Of Action For Burnley

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Burnley FC and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

Premier League Makes £4.464billion - 2 Packages Left

It has been confirmed this evening that the Premier League have earned £4.464billion with five television packages now sold.

Change Of Scenery Can Re-ignite Our Season

Midfielder Jack Cork has said that a change of scenery for the Burnley first team can help us re-ignite our season and get back to winning ways.

Get Our Heads Together And Go Again

Burnley skipper Ben Mee has said the side will dust themselves off from defeat to Swansea City this weekend and we'll be ready to go again in the next fixture.

Burnley Archived Articles

Vital Burnley articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Burnley
Write For Vital Burnley
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

Swansea MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Berg Gudmundsson6%
Sub - Arfield0%
Sub - Wells0%
Sub - Nkoudou0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Burnley Results (view all)

Burnley Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Grimsby Claret11
3.Portsrewart claret5
The Vital Football Members League